Our Menu
← Back to store
Appetizers
HOMEMADE MOZZARELLA STICKS
LEGENDARY! Our own Fried Mozzarella served with a side of our Homemade Marinara Sauce.
CHEESY GARLIC BREAD
An entire sliced loaf of our "Famous" Homemade Rolls with Garlic Butter & Mozzarella Cheese. Served with a side of our Homemade Marinara Sauce.
SAMPLER PLATTER
A Delicious Mix of our Homemade Mozzarella Sticks, Jalapeno Poppers, & Zucchini Sticks. Served with sides of our Homemade Marinara and Ranch Dressing.
RICE BALLS
Four Jumbo-Sized Sicilian Rice Balls made with Italian Arborio Rice & Cheese. Served side of our Homemade Marinara Sauce.
LOADED FRIES
A BHS Favorite! French Fries topped with Crispy Bacon & Cheddar Cheese served with a side of our Ranch Dressing.
Wings
Choice of Bone-In (Unbreaded) or Bone-Less (Breaded) Jumbo Wings Served in Your Choice of Spicy Buffalo, Mild, BBQ, Sweet Chili, or Teriyaki Sauces. Includes Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing.
Salads
Salads
Please note that if you are ordering a Salad with Chicken you MUST start with the type of Chicken Salad and then you can make modifications.
TOSSED SALAD
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers. Choice of Dressing Served on the Side.
TOSSED SALAD with MOZZARELLA
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with our Shredded Mozzarella Cheese. Choice of Dressing Served on the Side.
TOSSED SALAD with GORGONZOLA
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with Crumbled Gorgonzola Cheese. Choice of Dressing Served on the Side.
GREEK SALAD
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with Feta Cheese and Kalamata Olives. Served with our House Vinaigrette Dressing on the Side.
CHEF'S SALAD
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, topped with Rolled Slices of Ham, Turkey, & Genoa Salami, Shredded Mozzarella Cheese, and Kalamata Olives. Choice of Dressing Served on the Side.
GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with Grilled Slices of Chicken Breast. Choice of Dressing Served on the Side.
GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD
Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Parmesan, & Croutons topped with Grilled Slices of Chicken Breast. Served with a side of our Creamy Caesar Dressing.
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with Spicy Crispy Chicken. Served with our Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing.
CAJUN GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD
Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with Spicy Grilled Slices of Chicken Breast. Served with our Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing.
CRISPY CHICKEN SALAD
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, & Cucumbers topped with Strips of our Homemade Breaded Chicken Cutlet. Choice of Dressing Served on the Side.
METRO CHICKEN SALAD
Fresh Field Greens, Sundried Cranberries, Walnuts, Crumbled Gorgonzola, Fresh Apples, & Grilled Chicken. Served with a side of our House Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing.
NY Style Pizza
NY Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza cut into 8 slices. Large (16") serves 3-4 people. Small (12") serves 2-3 people
CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA
MAKE-YOUR-OWN KIT **COOK AT HOME**
Includes Small Size Dough Ball, Cheese, & Sauce. Choice of any 1 Regular Topping. Also available in Gluten-Free, Cauliflower, & Heart Shaped Crusts.
Signature Pizzas
THE GODFATHER
FAMOUS SPECIAL
SOPHIA'S WHITE PIZZA WITH SPINACH
PRIMAVERA
GEORGE'S BBQ CHICKEN
BUFFALO CHICKEN
CHICKEN TACO
MARGHERITA
SALAD
Sicilian Pizza
Small 12" Pan Pizza cut into 4 corner slices.
VODKA
Served "Upside Down Style" (Cheese under Sauce). Select to add Toppings (including 1/2 toppings).
GRANDMA'S
Just like Grandma used to make! Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Plum Tomato Sauce, Garlic, Olive Oil and topped with Fresh Basil.
BARNUM SQUARE
Regular Sicilian with Pepperoni, Ricotta, & Hot Honey Drizzle! Make it a "Drunken" Barnum Square by selecting Vodka Sauce instead of Tomato Sauce!
Tavern Style Pizza
Thin & Crispy! Available in Small (12") or Large (16") cut into 8 slices.
CREATE YOUR OWN TAVERN STYLE PIZZA
Gluten Free Pizzas
CAULIFLOWER CRUST
10" Personal Size Thin Seasoned Cauliflower Crust Pizza (Gluten-Free, not Dairy Free)
Heart Shaped Pizza
HEART SHAPED PIZZA
12" size only. Select to add Toppings (including 1/2 toppings). For Specialty Pizzas you must order from the NY Style Pizza section. Choose the SMALL SIZE of the specialty pizza you want to order and select HEART SHAPED from the crust tab.
Calzones
Create Your Own Calzone using Our Pizza Toppings (Regular Toppings $1.00 each - Deluxe Toppings $2.00 each)
CHEESE
A Half-Moon Pocket of Dough stuffed with Ricotta & Mozarella Cheeses. Served with a side of our Homemade Marinara Sauce.
MEAT LOVERS
Our Best Seller! Pepperoni, Meatballs, Italian Sausage, Crispy Bacon, Mozzarella & Ricotta. Served with a side of Marinara.
VEGGIE LOVERS
All FRESH Veggies! Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers, Broccoli, Mozzarella & Ricotta. Served with a side of Marinara.
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Hot Sauce, & Mozzarella Cheese (No Ricotta Cheese). Served with a side of Blue Cheese.
CHICKEN PARM
Breaded Chicken Cutlet & Mozzarella Cheese (No Ricotta Cheese). Served with a side of Marinara.
Grinders
All Grinders are served on our Famous Focaccia-Style Homemade Rolls and toasted. Fries & Onion Rings are available under the Appetizers section. Wraps include a bag of Chips.
CHICKEN PARMESAN
Our Best Seller! Homemade Breaded Chicken Cutlet topped with our Homemade Marinara Sauce, & Mozzarella Cheese.
MEATBALL PARMESAN
An Italian Favorite of Hearty Meatballs topped with our Homade Marinara Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
SAUSAGE PARMESAN
Sweet Italian Sausage Links topped with our Homade Marinara Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
EGGPLANT PARMESAN
Lightly Battered Eggplant Cutlets topped with our Homade Marinara Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
CHICKEN CUTLET
A Bethel Favorite of our Homemade Breaded Chicken Cutlet served with Lettuce, Tomato, American Cheese, & Mayo.
GRILLED CHICKEN
Grilled Chicken with Fresh Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato & Balsamic Glaze Drizzle.
TUSCAN CHICKEN
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, & Balsamic Glaze.
PHILLY CHEESE STEAK
Shaved Steak served with American Cheese, Sauteed Onions & Roasted Red Peppers.
BETHEL CHEESE STEAK
Shaved Steak served with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Mayo.
ITALIAN COMBO
Boars Head Ham & Genoa Salami with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & House Dressing.
TURKEY CLUB
Boars Head Turkey Breast with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, & Spicy Chipotle Aioli
Wraps
All Wraps are 100% Whole Wheat and include a bag of Chips (Grinders do not include Chips). Fries & Onion Rings are available under the Appetizers section
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Spicy Crispy Chicken with Lettuce, Tomato, Buffalo Sauce & Blue Cheese Dressing
CHICKEN CAESAR
Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, Shredded Parmesan, & Caesar Dressing
GRILLED CHICKEN CLUB
Grilled Chicken with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, & Honey Mustard Dressing
MARGHERITA CHICKEN
Grilled Chicken with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato, Fresh Basil, & Balsamic Glaze.
RAGIN' CAJUN CHICKEN
Spicy Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, Tomato & Blue Cheese Dressing
METRO CHICKEN
Grilled Chicken with Field Greens, Dries Cranberries, Walnuts, Gorgonzola, & Balsamic Glaze.
Pasta
All Pasta Dishes are Served with our Homemade Bread.
PENNE with MARINARA SAUCE
Additional Toppings include Italian Meatballs, Sweet Italian Sausage, & Meat Sauce.
RAVIOLI with MEATBALLS
Jumbo Cheese Ravioli served with Italian Meatballs in our Homemade Marinara Sauce.
LASAGNA
A Jumbo Sized Portion with Layers of Pasta, Ground Beef/Pork, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Parmesan & Marinara.
PENNE with GRILLED CHICKEN & BROCCOLI
Penne with Grilled Chicken, Broccoli, Garlic, Oil, & Shredded Parmesan.
Desserts
CHOCOLATE MOUSSE CAKE
A Slice of very Light Chocolate Mousse with an Oreo Crust topped with Whipped Cream and Chocolate Shavings.
REESE'S CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
A Slice of Graham-Peanut Butter Crust cradles layers of Chocolate, Caramel, & Peanut Butter Mousse. Topped with Whipped Cream & Chunks of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
CHOCOLATE CHIP BROWNIE
An American Favorite made with Pure Melted Chocolate & loaded with Sweet Chocolate Morsels
Catering
Most Catering Items Require Advance Notice. Please call us at 203-797-1550 and ask for Perry to discuss all your Catering needs including options not shown such as Wrap & Grinder Platters. Half Trays feed approx 8-10 & Full Trays feed approx 16-20. Paper Goods are available free of charge upon request.
Tossed Salad
Crisp Romaine & Iceberg Blend, Tomatoes, Green Peppers, & Cucumbers
Chicken Fingers
Half Tray 30pcs - Full Tray 60pcs - Served with Honey Mustard on the side.
JALAPENO POPPERS
Filled with Cheddar Cheese. Includes side(s) of Ranch Dressing.
Pasta
Choice of Penne or Linguine. Includes our Homemade Marinara Sauce or choose to add Meatballs. Other Options include Grilled Chicken with Brocolli, Garlic, & Oil or a Plain Butter Sauce.
Drinks
Sodas
20oz BOTTLE
Select to choose from Coke, Coke Zero, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper, Diet Dr Pepper, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Orange, Grape, Lime Seltzer, Berry Seltzer, Lemonade & Pink Lemonade
2Liter BOTTLE
Select to choose from Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Orange, & Lemonade
Other Drinks
Vitamin Water
Select to choose from XXX Acai Blueberry Pomeganate, Energy Tropical Citrus, or Squeezed Lemonade (Zero Sugar)